I love freezing cakes and cupcakes. I actually think they taste better and are more moist when they’re frozen first. If you freeze them the right way, there is no way anyone can tell that they’ve been frozen…as long as you follow these tips 😉
I like to do things ahead of time. I’m not really a procrastinator and I’m not one of those people who thrive on last minute stress. I like to bake my cakes in advance and I thought why not share with you how I freeze them. I think there are a lot of people who don’t realize that you CAN freeze cakes and cupcakes successfully.
Freezing cakes and cupcakes is such a time saver, especially if you have a cake business as a side job, or if you just like doing things ahead of time.
How to Freeze Cakes & Cupcakes:
I never have freezer burn on my cakes, probably because I go a little overboard on wrapping them, but I thought I’d share with you my tips and tricks.
By the way, you can get to two of my favorite cake recipes by clicking these links:
Favorite Vanilla Bean Cake Recipe
This post contains affiliate links, which means I will receive a referral commission, at no additional cost to you, if you make a purchase using these links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. These links also use cookies, which tracks and allows me to get credit for the referral. You can see my policies linked in the website footer.
Freezing Cakes:
When I pull my cakes out of the oven, I set them on racks to cool for 10 minutes. I don’t let them sit in their pans any longer than that.
After ten minutes, I then turn them out of their pans and onto the racks to cool completely. I’ve heard of people actually wrapping their warm cakes and sticking them directly into the freezer, but honestly that makes me a little nervous. Isn’t it moisture that causes freezer burn? I just don’t want steam in there when I wrap them up, so I let them cool almost completely.
I may have mentioned it a time or two, but I have a love-affair with Press-n-Seal Wrap. I can’t seem to work regular saran wrap. Call me weird, but it always just crinkles up on me and sticks to itself. I find TOO clingy. Press-n-seal is just so much easier to use.
I take a large piece of press-n-seal and set it sticky side down on the counter, set my cake layer on it and wrap it up. (Oh, yeah, I also go ahead and cut the domes off the cakes, if there are any. You don’t have to do this right now though. You can certainly do this after you’ve defrosted them.)
I then set a second piece of press-n-seal sticky side up on my counter, set the cake (seam side down) on it and wrap it up.
Next I take a strip of foil and wrap them up. Here’s my method: I press down the ends of the foil, fold them in like a present and then roll up the ends. Wrapping it like that, keeps the foil from denting into the cake, or causing the cake to get misshapen.
After I’ve wrapped it once with foil, I’ll place the cake layer (seam side of the foil face down) and then wrap it up all over again.
I’ll then put a piece of tape on the top and write what kind of cake it is, the size and the date.
Yes I do use a lot of materials, but like I said, I never get freezer burn. It’s possible you only really need one layer of foil, and that’s totally okay if you’re making cakes for home, but when I was selling cakes, I wanted to be dang sure, they were as fresh as I could get them and just went the extra mile.
By the way, you can find the video on the process toward the end of the post!
How to Freeze Cupcakes:
Freezing cupcakes is almost the same procedure. I take my cupcakes out of the oven and let them set in the pan, on the rack for ten minutes.
Then I take my cupcakes out of the pan and set them on the racks to cool almost completely.
I spread out a strip of press-n-seal (sticky side down) and set 6 to 8 cupcakes on it and then wrap it up.
I then set another strip of press-n-seal on the counter (sticky side up) and wrap them up again.
Next, I place one or two of these cupcake packets into a gallon freezer bag. I label the bag with the flavor and date.
Again, it may be a little overkill with the wrapping, but I’d rather be safe than sorry and I’ve never had a cake or cupcake come out of the freezer with freezer burn. Another tip is that I don’t like to keep my cakes frozen over three weeks.
How to Defrost Cakes and Cupcakes:
I think most people would assume you just take the cakes or cupcakes out of the freezer and their packaging to let them defrost, but YOU DON’T WANT TO DO THAT! Ok, I’m sorry I yelled at you, but I had to get your attention.
Here’s what you DO want to do: Take your cakes or cupcakes out of the freezer, but leave them in their packaging to defrost. The reason? Well, defrosting will cause some condensation and if you leave them in their packaging, then the condensation will form on the outside of the packaging and NOT on your cakes or cupcakes.
Too much moisture on your cakes can cause air bubbles when you try to ice it. The icing may go on smoothly, but a couple hours later, you’ll look at the cake and there will be a blow out or icing bubble on the side of it. As for cupcakes, if you allow condensation to build on the actual cupcake, it could cause the liners to pull away from the cupcake, or perhaps the icing won’t stick to the cupcake.
Ok, now it’s your turn to try freezing your cakes and cupcakes and tell me what you think! I think you’ll be surprised at how fresh they taste…liked you just baked them actually.
Oh and here’s a quick video I made to show you the whole process!
GET THE FREE FREEZING CAKES & CUPCAKES TIP SHEET PLUS THE PASSWORD TO THE RESOURCE LIBRARY. Just fill out the form below!
Don’t Forget to Pin it for Later!
Josie says
September 7, 2016 at 8:34 amNew at this. Frustrated with freezer snafus. (Had always stared at the PressnSeal to use for freezing) You made my day! Thank you!
Kara Jane says
September 9, 2016 at 5:33 amAwesome! I LOVE my press n seal. If they ever discontinue it for some reason, I might actually cry! Lol 😉
Debbie says
September 9, 2016 at 12:42 amHow long are they good for once they are frozen???
Kara Jane says
September 9, 2016 at 5:31 amI usually keep them frozen for about three weeks or so and they always taste fine for me.
Leah says
February 21, 2017 at 7:35 pmBelieve it or not I had a bride have to postpone her wedding for nearly a year. Sorry to say the cake was on the counter ready to frost. I told her I’d wrap and freeze for a month or so but that she would have to take to her own freezer for the balance if time. We even froze the frosting.
I explained ( she had already paid) that as long as the cake and frosting tasted to my and her satisfaction when thawed I wouldn’t charge her any more to put together on her new date. Well come time we tasted and they were great. I did have to rebake 3 layers , 1 for damage in freezer and 2 other layers because they ate them lol. Wrap tight and the taste will stay amazing
Kara Jane says
February 21, 2017 at 9:48 pmWow, they lasted that long!? I’m impressed! That is so funny that they couldn’t keep from eating some of it. hahaha!
linda philley says
September 9, 2016 at 9:08 amthank you I always bake at Christmas and I have to stand on my feet baking for 2 days and then I hurt for a week. Do you know or can you freeze truffles without them sweating after you take them out– another big problem .Right now I just stand on my feet for another day and make them instead of freezing them
Kara Jane says
September 9, 2016 at 9:24 amMy pleasure 🙂 I’m the queen of doing everything ahead of time. I don’t like stressing out at the last minute. As far as freezing truffles…I’ve never tried it. That would be a good experiment though. It might work if you set each truffle on the press n seal, sticky side up, but space them apart a little. Then put another piece of press n seal, sticky side down, on top of them. Then you can take your finger and seal the press n seal around each truffle, then seal the edges of the press n seal together. I’d wrap them in foil and then put in a ziplock freezer bag. I do something similar to fondant decorations I want to keep fresh. I’ve got a post coming up that explains it. If you try it, let me know if it works! 😉
Eleanor says
September 10, 2016 at 3:37 pmWhat is the Scottish equivalent to press and seal? Great tips, thank you
Kara Jane says
September 10, 2016 at 3:55 pmOh my goodness, I have no idea, but if you don’t see it in your grocery store next to the regular Saran Wrap or foil wrap, you might try online. Or you could always take a fun trip to the US! 😉
Gerville says
September 10, 2016 at 7:41 pmVery informative
Shelley says
September 14, 2016 at 10:25 amI despise cling wrap as well. I make a huge mess and still don’t have anything wrapped!! I’ve developed an obsession for press n seal!! It’s just so reliable & easy to use!! I love to bake, but have been nervous about freezing! Thanks for this!
Kara Jane says
September 14, 2016 at 11:16 amHaha!! That’s exactly what I think of cling wrap! I just end up losing my temper with it 😉
Glad I could help!
Rose says
September 14, 2016 at 11:54 pmI’m planning to bake and decorate the cake for my daughter’s first birthday. I’m kind of nervous as I’ve never done it before for a group of people. I’ll be freezing it so that I’m not rushing with the cooking and decorations. I just hope it doesn’t taste like my freezer after it’s been in there for a week!!!
Kara Jane says
September 15, 2016 at 6:25 amJust make sure and wrap it twice with the press n seal and twice with the foil and it’ll be fine. It’s only going to be in there for a week, so you should be good. Just remember when you take it out, let it defrost still wrapped up.
Nomie says
September 16, 2016 at 7:50 amI am so happy l found yiur blog. It is very imformative. I do have a couple of questions though.
How far ahead does one start defrosting a cake?
Also, defrost in the fridge or out?
Kara Jane says
September 16, 2016 at 8:37 amGlad I could help 😉 As far as defrosting goes…it depends on how big the cake layers are. Cupcakes will defrost rather quickly (maybe 30 minutes or so). Bigger cake layers may take an hour. Leave them in their wrappings when you defrost them. Just defrost them on the counter. I set mine out and about an hour later, I unwrap them, unless it’s a larger cake layer and then I leave it wrapped on the counter a little longer.
Dian Nova says
September 22, 2016 at 1:56 amHi, Kara…
i never freezing any cakes i’ve made, maybe i’ll try later 😀
after you defrost it, then?
eat it directly or you have to warm it again?
thanks
Kara Jane says
September 22, 2016 at 6:34 amJust defrost it in its wrappings. Once it’s defrosted, take the wrappings off and you can either serve it right away, or ice it and serve it. You don’t need to warm it up. The cake will be fine sitting on the counter for a couple days if it’s covered in a cake server or wrap it again with press-n-seal. You will have to refrigerate it if there are perishable fillings or if you’re using an egg white based buttercream to ice it. If you use the American buttercream (with butter and confectioners sugar), it’s fine to leave it on the counter, covered, for a couple days.
Martese says
September 22, 2016 at 8:50 pmAnother little tip I learned from managing an ice cream store is to frost the cake while still frozen. So much quicker because the cake is solid, and the frozen cake helps to chill and set up the frosting, plus traps in the moisture from the defrosting cake. Everyone always asks how my cakes and cupcakes are so moist! That’s my trick.
Kara Jane says
September 25, 2016 at 3:55 pmGood tip. I personally haven’t had much luck icing frozen cakes. I seem to get icing blow outs when I do that, but it may because I don’t typically chill my cakes afterwards. I leave them room temp. It’s never worked for me when I’ve had to cover a cake in fondant, but that doesn’t mean it won’t work for others. Good tip if you plan to keep your cakes chilled afterwards.
Christi says
March 27, 2019 at 8:40 amWhat is your experience with cupcakes and keeping the wrappers from coming off? I find my cupcake wrappers always seem to start coming off when my cupcakes are cooling.
Kara Jane says
March 27, 2019 at 7:18 pmOh yeah I’ve had trouble with certain cupcake liners doing that. It’s weird, but it seems like the more expensive and thick they are, the more they pull away. That may be all in my head…I don’t know. Anyway, I think it could be the type of liners, but also I think the bigger problem is moisture. There’s a good post by my friend Rose at Rose Bakes who wrote more about it. She actually gives a bunch of different reasons why it happens. It’s a really helpful article. Here’s the link if you’d like to read that post: https://rosebakes.com/cupcake-liners-pull-away-cupcakes/ I hope it helps!
Debbie says
December 22, 2016 at 7:30 pmCan I freeze a cake that is done with butter cream and fondant
Kara Jane says
December 22, 2016 at 7:56 pmHi Debbie, I prefer to freeze my buttercream separate from my cake. You can put mounds of buttercream on plastic wrap, wrap it and then twist the ends and put it in a ziplock freezer bag. If the buttercream is already on the cake, you can probably freeze it all together and the taste should be just fine. It won’t be a smooth buttercream finish though. Also, when you take it out of the freezer, you’ll need to leave it on the counter to defrost a bit, but leave the wrapping on it. Let the condensation form on the outside of the wrapping, then you can unwrap it before the buttercream gets too soft.
As far as freezing a cake that is covered with fondant, I have never personally tried it, but my friend Rose has and it seemed to work for her. Here is a link where she talks about it: http://rosebakes.com/can-freeze-fondant-decorated-cake/ Hope this helps you!
Michelle says
January 14, 2017 at 2:19 amI do the same thing when freezing my cakes. I do go one step beyond, because my freezer is so tightly packed. I freeze my cakes on a board. I simply wrap the board with tin foil before I place my wrapped cake on it. That way Im sure to not wreck my cake before it’s frozen. You are right though. It works everytime!
Kara Jane says
January 14, 2017 at 2:15 pmThat is a great idea! Thank you for sharing!
Vivian says
February 4, 2017 at 11:04 pmThanks so much for your ideas I am new at this.
Kara Jane says
February 5, 2017 at 12:04 pmVivian, you’re so welcome 😉
Cindy says
February 21, 2017 at 7:51 pmHi
How do you store your muffins?
I love make banana muffins.
When I store them in ziploc bags and the next day they are WET. I’ve tried other bags and containers, next I tried other recipes. Haven’t found anything yet.
Help.
Kara Jane says
February 21, 2017 at 9:54 pmHi Cindy, I don’t make muffins often, but I do make cupcakes a lot and I store them a little differently than I do my cakes. You might try it with muffins and see if it makes a difference. Here’s a link to the post I wrote about it. https://iscreamforbuttercream.com/keep-cupcakes-from-drying-out/ Basically, I just keep them in a plastic container. I just set them in the container without wrapping them, then close the container and wrap the outside where the lid snaps shut. They may have a little moisture on the top, but they shouldn’t be wet. Just make sure they’re cooled down when you put them in the container. Hope this helps!
Sao says
February 25, 2017 at 1:36 amHow long does it usually take to defrost a cake ? And do you defrost it completely before unwrapping and using it ? Help! My first time doing this!!!
Kara Jane says
February 25, 2017 at 8:33 amIt really depends on the size of the cake. Usually what I do is take the cake out of the freezer and just set it on my counter. Leave it wrapped. I let mine sit out like this for at least an hour and sometimes a bit more. Condensation will form on the outside of the wrappings instead of on the cake when you allow them to defrost in their wrappings…that’s a good thing. I like to let mine come to room temp before icing them. I know some decorators like to ice their cakes cold, but I haven’t had much luck with that. It seems like I get icing blowouts (big bubbles under the icing) when I do that, so I prefer mine to be completely defrosted and almost room temp before I start decorating. Hope this helps!
Carmi says
August 11, 2017 at 12:28 pmHi Kara
I am making a 4 tier wedding cake for 29th September, how far ahead can I make it and freeze it???
Going onto to amazon to get press and seal, looks a great product, we don’t have it here in Ireland? But hooray ? for amazon!!!!!!
Kara Jane says
August 11, 2017 at 1:16 pmOh yes…the wonders of Amazon! There are tons of things I don’t have available near me, so it’s my saving grace 😉 Ok, onto your question. When I freeze my cakes, I don’t like to leave them frozen longer than two weeks. Really, it’s probably fine up to a month, but if it’s a cake I’m doing for a client, I don’t freeze it over two weeks. Once I’m ready to start the decorating process, I just let them defrost on the counter in their wrappings. Then I’ll unwrap and start decorating. Hope this helps 🙂
fem says
October 19, 2017 at 12:09 amhi karen thank you so much for wonderful tips. question If i take out my cake from freezer Do I have to remove the wrap or no in right away while defrost? how many hour to wait if ready to frost the cake.
Kara Jane says
October 19, 2017 at 9:33 amWhen you take your cakes out of the freezer, just set them on your kitchen counter with the wrapping still on. Don’t take the wrappings off until they’re defrosted because that’ll cause a lot of condensation on the actual cake. The amount of time it takes to defrost your cake will depend on the size of your cake layers. I would leave them on the counter, still in the wrappings, for at least an hour before taking the wrappings off. A lot of times, what I do is take them out that morning, set them on the counter to defrost in their wrappings and then that afternoon, I’ll take the wrappings off and decorate them. Hope this helps!
Jack Allen says
November 22, 2017 at 3:33 amHi Kara,
I am so glad I found your website, because I been looking all night to see how can I defrost a cake. I made them about a week ago because I do not want to be in the kitchen all day Thanksgiving. It is my year to cook so I had to plan ahead. Wish me luck I will be taking them out the freezer at 7am and frosting them around 3pm when I get up for work. ??
Kara Jane says
November 22, 2017 at 8:41 amOh wonderful! Glad I could help and I hope all goes well with it! 🙂
Jack Allen says
November 22, 2017 at 4:49 pmKara hello both cakes I froze last week turn out great when I got ready to put the icing on. ???
Kara Jane says
November 22, 2017 at 6:46 pmWoo hoo! Yay! 🙂
Debbie says
December 19, 2017 at 11:07 pmThanks for the info! I enjoy baking, but I just do it for my family. I have, however, been an event planner/catering coordinator and have done Lots of weddings. People often think they can’t save their top cake for their anniversary because it will taste like the freezer, but they’re wrong! I know, I saved mine and it was perfect! I used layers of Saran Wrap (press and seal would be great too) and tin foil as you do, but the biggest key for extended freezing, paper bags! I used two. They absorb any smells that may be in the freezer and help keep it fresh. I don’t know about you, but I have to use my freezer for a lot of things, and I don’t want my cake tasting or smelling like anything other than cake!
Thanks for your tips!
Kara Jane says
December 20, 2017 at 8:48 amHi Debbie, what a great tip! I’ve actually never thought about using paper bags to help with freezing, but it makes total sense when you explained it. Thanks so much for the tip…I’ll definitely try it out! 🙂
Esther says
January 31, 2018 at 2:57 pmHi, Kara! Thank you so much for this tutorial! I found it sometime last year and it has been such a huge help. I’m baking for five weddings between now and April (the first is tomorrow!), as well as numerous Unicorn cakes over the coming weeks, and your wrapping tips are sensational. I had never used Press ‘N Seal until you mentioned it! Now, I use it all the time!
Kara Jane says
January 31, 2018 at 6:06 pmOh wonderful! And wow, you are a busy lady! It’s great that you’ve got so many cake orders! Yes, I will admit that press n seal soon becomes an obsession. The kids are always joking that they’ll buy it for me for Christmas and birthday gifts. LOL. I’m so glad you found the post helpful! 🙂
Nicole says
March 7, 2018 at 12:04 pmHi Kara! I am making my own wedding cake and have already completed the baking, wrapping and freezing part ?
The cakes are freezing in my deep freeze at home, but my wedding is taking place in a different town where I’m going to be assembling the cake on a Friday! We are leaving our house on Thursday and my plan was to defrost my cakes on the Thursday and keep them cold until Friday when I assemble the cake. What would be your suggestion for a successful outcome in this situation?!
Thanks for your help!
Kara Jane says
March 7, 2018 at 2:33 pmHi Nicole, Wow…you’ve got a job ahead of you…you’re one brave gal! 😉 Ok, I think defrosting them and keeping them chilled until Friday will work just fine. Honestly, I don’t assemble my cakes cold, so personally I would set them out on the counter an hour or so before assembling that way they’re closer to room temp, but if you’re more comfortable assembling them cold, do what’s most comfortable. I just find that icing cold cakes can sometimes cause buttercream blowouts and air bubbles. Some people have different methods though. Hope this helps!
Gale says
March 9, 2018 at 2:03 pmHi Kara,
So glad I found your site!! Yours seem easier to understand and do. I have a question. So if I freeze both cake layers and frosting ahead, defrost them, then decorate; can I put them in the frig for one day all assembled, then place them to go to room temperature that day? Will it condensate in the frig? Help, I have never done this, always wanted to. This cake is for my granddaughters 1st birthday, and want it special. Hope it turns out, or there goes the emergency trip to the store!
Kara Jane says
March 9, 2018 at 4:14 pmI usually defrost everything at room temp. When I decorate, I usually just keep everything room temp, unless there’s something perishable in the filling or icing. (Regular American buttercream is fine to be left out on the counter.)
When I fill my cakes, I usually do a super thin crumb coat on the cake and then cover it loosely with saran wrap or press-n-seal. I leave it out of the fridge and wait a couple hours if I can to let the cake ‘settle’ before adding the final coat of buttercream to the outside. I do this because by letting the cake settle, you’re less likely to get air bubbles (buttercream blowouts) or icing ridges in your final cake.
So…After you decorate the cake, it really doesn’t hurt it to keep it in the fridge. I tend to leave mine, out, but it’s fine to keep it chilled if you’re more comfortable with that. You do run the risk of it getting condensation on it once you set it out though. If you’re using dark buttercream colors, it might be an issue, but if it’s all white buttercream, usually that’s fine. If you keep it in the fridge, just keep it in a cake box and then I usually cover my box with press n seal or regular saran wrap. When you take it out of the fridge, just leave it in the box covered on the counter or table for at least half an hour before you open it up and hopefully then the condensation will stay on the outside of the box and not on the cake. I hope all that made sense!
Krystal Ramsawak-Husain says
July 24, 2018 at 1:31 amHi Kara, I’m a new subscriber and I understand that this was an old post, but still hoping you’ll entertain me. I live in the Caribbean where it’s either always raining or very, very hot. I’ve had two experiences with cake bubbles or blow outs under my fondant (it’s ugly)… But because our room temperature here turns butter into oil, I’m thinking of using an air conditioned room… But what’s the highest temperature you might recommend? Also, why does moisture cause the blow outs tho? I’m sorry… I’ve been trying to get an answer for what causes the blow outs and you’re the first to offer a solution. I’m just trying to grasp the science.
Kara Jane says
July 24, 2018 at 8:28 pmHi Krystal. I understand the problem with blow outs…they can definitely be a real pain. I’ll tell you what I do to prevent blowouts that seems to really help. I decorate my cakes at room temperature. My room temp is about 72-77 F. I wouldn’t go too much warmer than that or your buttercream will get soft, like you mentioned in your comment. I seem to get the blow outs when I don’t let the cake layers settle. Basically what I do is just add the cake layers and filling and then cover the cake lightly with wrap. I don’t cover it in buttercream or anything else yet. I keep it room temp and let it settle either over night, or a couple hours at least. This lets any air that’s trapped between the layers come out. It just allows the cake and buttercream to settle. Once it’s settled, I then cover it in buttercream, ganache, or whatever I’m decorating with. I don’t refrigerate my cakes, unless there’s some kind of perishable filling. I’ve found when I chill them first and then decorate them, somehow condensation forms between the cake and the icing and that’s when a blow out can occur.
I know that many cake decorators have no problem chilling cakes and decorating them cold etc., but I have always had issues when I do that. If it’s chilled, decorated and then chilled again immediately, you may not have any problems with blowouts until it comes to room temp.
As far as the science behind the blowouts…I really don’t know exactly. It’s like a combination of the condensation (moisture) that’s on the chilled cake, not allowing the buttercream to really adhere and/or it could be air trapped in the cake the comes out because it wasn’t allowed to fully settle before adding the outside buttercream or fondant.
My answer was pretty long, but I hope it’s at least a little helpful!
Em says
August 25, 2018 at 11:38 amPlease how do I retain the colour of my red velvet cake, each time I freeze it and take it out for use, the colour dims.
Kara Jane says
August 25, 2018 at 7:19 pmHmmm that’s interesting. I’m not exactly sure I have an answer for you. I’d just make sure to cover it really well in addition to covering it with foil. Let it defrost while still in the wrappings and see if that helps.
Victoria says
November 1, 2018 at 8:55 pmHi there!
Am I able to bake and frost cupcakes and then freeze them? I have a function and I will be out of town up until the morning of the event. I was hoping to make the cupcakes a week ahead of time and freeze them. Any thoughts? How would I successfully wrap frosted cupcakes to prevent freezer burn?
Kara Jane says
November 1, 2018 at 9:22 pmI don’t normally freeze them with the icing on, but I know it can be done. The only thing I would worry about though is condensation that might cause the icing to slide off the cupcakes when they defrost, but I don’t know if that would actually happen. What you could try is once they’re baked and iced, pop them in the freezer for just a little bit, like maybe 10 minutes or so and let them get pretty firm. Then pull them out and wrap them up in plastic wrap and add them to a ziplock bag, then pop back into the freezer. The only thing is that normally when you take cake out of the freezer to defrost, you’d leave the wrappings on while it defrosts so that the condensation is on the outside of the wrappings and not the cake itself. However with the cupcakes already being iced, if you don’t take the plastic wrap off them before they defrost then the icing could get messed up, but then you’d be dealing with condensation on them that may or may not cause issues. You could freeze the cupcakes and the buttercream separately and then ice them once they all defrost, or you could get a plastic container that has a cover and freeze them in that. That may work better because then you could leave the lid on them while they defrost. I know this answer was a bit long, but I’m just thinking out loud. 😉 I hope this helps!
Madison says
January 27, 2019 at 2:47 pmHi! I’m hoping you’ll still be able/willing to respond even though this is post is a few years old.
I followed your instructions and froze a batch of cupcakes and then thawed them on my counter at room temp in their wrap, but my cupcakes, while moist and wonderful inside, are sooo incredibly sticky outside! I’m at a loss for what to do. Please help D:
Kara Jane says
January 27, 2019 at 3:28 pmHi Madison. Yes cupcakes tend to do that quite often after they’ve been frozen, or even just chilled. (Well that’s my experience anyway.) At least you know your cupcakes are moist, right? Sometimes I just lay a paper towel over them and press down gently. That can soak up a bit of that moisture and it seems to help. You could just let them sit out for a bit after you’ve used the paper towel trick and let the tops dry out some, but I don’t like to do that because generally cupcakes dry out really quickly and I don’t want the whole cupcake to be dry. The second thing is after using the paper towel, I just don’t worry about the tops being moist or sticky. They’ll have icing on them and generally that will cover up anything, so it should be fine. Let me know if you have anymore questions!
Linet Swanepoel says
February 11, 2019 at 1:58 amHi Kara. I love this post of yours. I have to bake my sister-in-laws wedding cake for April (my first wedding cake.nervous…) Can I use wax paper to cover my cakes before freezing them?
Kara Jane says
February 11, 2019 at 3:58 pmHi I’m so glad the post was helpful! I have never tried using wax paper. I’m not sure if it would seal it as well as the plastic wrap and foil though, so I can’t promise anything. I wouldn’t test it on her cake though. I mean if you have time to test it on a smaller cake beforehand, you could, but I know it’s safe to use the plastic wrap and foil though. Hope this helps.
carol says
March 14, 2019 at 11:58 amI love this very helpful site of yours, but I don’t know how to do the step of pasting! anyway I am on your site and I love it and learned so much! Thanks, Carol
Kara Jane says
March 14, 2019 at 3:00 pmHi Carol, I’m glad you’re finding it helpful! Glad to have you here! 🙂
Christina Villanueva says
May 13, 2019 at 5:45 pmHave you froze a cake with fruit in it? I’m planning on making a blueberry lemon cake. I would love to make further in advance than a few day. my concern with freezing would be what would the frozen blueberries to the sponge during defrosting.
thanks for the tips!
Kara Jane says
May 13, 2019 at 6:37 pmChristina, I don’t remember if I’ve ever frozen a blueberry cake before. I know I’ve frozen blueberry pancakes and they were totally fine when defrosted. I’ve frozen banana cake and strawberry cake and they were also fine. I’m thinking it should probably be fine though.
Donna says
June 16, 2019 at 8:32 amWow! What great instructions and comments!!!
I have a buttercake request. 3tiers, choc and vanilla. I am nervous about stacking buttercake, but with dowel and cardboard cakeboards between the layers I am hopeful (hevens help me if it doesn’t!!)
My concern is around if I freeze and then bring back to room temp that the cake will be too crumbly and soft as I add the buttercream icing. Have you had this problem?
Kara Jane says
June 16, 2019 at 10:02 amHi Donna, If you cover your cake layers really well with plastic wrap and foil before freezing then defrost the cake in the wrapping, the texture of the cake shouldn’t change. Freezing it and defrosting it shouldn’t make it more crumbly…at least it hasn’t for me. I normally cover my buttercream cakes at room temperature, but some people like to chill their cakes before frosting. Just do what works for you.
As far as stacking goes, just make sure you’ve got a cake board under each tier and use dowels that are all cut the same size. Check that your tiers are level with a mini level. That’s important because if they aren’t sitting level, the cake could topple over. I have another post on the site that may help explain all that. You can find it here: https://iscreamforbuttercream.com/anatomy-of-a-decorated-cake/
I hope everything goes well!